Health Sciences
Resources
Basic InformationMore InformationLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersLinksBook Reviews
A Companion to GenethicsA Mind So RareA Mood ApartAcquiring GenomesAdaptive DynamicsAlterations of ConsciousnessAltered EgosAn Introduction to the Philosophy of MindAre We Hardwired?Being HumanBelief's Own EthicsBeyond GeneticsBiological Complexity and Integrative PluralismBody BazaarBrain Evolution and CognitionCloningCoherence in Thought and ActionConsciousness and the NovelConsciousness EmergingConsciousness EvolvingConsciousness in ActionConsciousness RecoveredConsciousness, Color, and ContentCreating Mental IllnessDarwinizing CultureDecoding DarknessDescriptions and PrescriptionsDynamics in ActionEmotionEmpathy and AgencyEvolutionEvolution and the Human MindEvolution's RainbowEvolutionary Origins of MoralityExploding the Gene MythFinding Consciousness in the BrainFrom Certainty to UncertaintyFurnishing the MindGenomeGetting HookedHeroes, Rogues, and LoversHeuristics and BiasesHow to Solve the Mind-Body ProblemHuman Nature and the Limits of ScienceHuman TrialsI of the VortexImproving Nature?In Our Own ImageIndividual Differences in Conscious ExperienceInformation ArtsIntelligence, Race, and GeneticsIntentions and IntentionalityMatters of the MindMind and MechanismModels of the SelfMy Double UnveiledNarrative and IdentityNaturalism and the Human ConditionNeurons and NetworksNorms of NatureOrigins of Human NatureOrigins of PsychopathologyOxford Guide to the MindPassionate EnginesPhilosophy and the NeurosciencesPhysicalism and Its DiscontentsPlaying God?PromiscuityProzac BacklashPsychiatry in the New MilleniumPsychological Concepts and Biological PsychiatryPsychological Dimensions of the SelfPsychologyRational Choice in an Uncertain WorldReclaiming CognitionRedesigning HumansSociological Perspectives on the New GeneticsSorting Things OutStrong FeelingsSurprise, Uncertainty, and Mental StructuresSynesthesia : A Union of the SensesThe Barmaid's BrainThe Birth of the MindThe Book of LifeThe Caldron of ConsciousnessThe Century of the GeneThe Cognitive Basis of ScienceThe Cognitive Neuroscience of ConsciousnessThe Conscious MindThe Debated MindThe Developing MindThe Dream DrugstoreThe Dynamic NeuronThe Empirical StanceThe Evolution of MindThe Illusion of Conscious WillThe Limits of Autobiography The Madness of Adam and EveThe Maladapted MindThe Mind's PastThe Misunderstood GeneThe Nature of ConsciousnessThe Nature of IntelligenceThe New PhrenologyThe Presence of MindThe Problem of the SoulThe Race for ConsciousnessThe Shattered SelfThe Significance of ConsciousnessThe Social Construction of What?The Terrible GiftThe Theory of OptionsThe Triumph of SociobiologyThe View from WithinThinks...Understanding CloningUnderstanding EmotionsUnderstanding the GenomeUp From DragonsWhat Genes Can't DoWhat It Means to Be 98 Percent ChimpanzeeWhere the Action IsWho Rules in ScienceWhy Smart People Can Be So StupidWhy We Lie
Related Topics

Medical Disorders
Mental Disorders
Mental Health Professions

by Ted Peters
Routledge, 2002
Review by Bryan Benham on May 31st 2003

Playing God?

The aim of this book, Playing God? Genetic Determinism and Human Freedom, is to examine a number of issues raised by genetic science within the context of a culturally and scientifically informed theological framework, what Peters identifies as a "response theology."  In particular, Peters is concerned to expose assumptions of the "gene-myth" that often leads religious thinkers to proclaim that we should stop genetic research or technology because it risks "playing God," revealing a certain human hubris that will ultimately be our moral downfall.  Peters' position throughout is that the "gene-myth" is just that, a myth.  It is founded on a mistaken understanding of genetics and human freedom, and at its worst threatens to deny certain potentially life-saving and life-enriching technologies.  Peters argues that the prohibition against genetic science because it is "playing God" is itself a misleading form of reasoning.  Responsible science does not play God.  In fact, Peters argues, genetic science is an exemplar of "playing human," an attempt to improve the human condition, decreasing present and future suffering.  This, he argues, is consistent with theological conceptions of humans as created co-creators and with the more secular ideas of beneficence.  The prohibition against "playing God" does little to further these worthy theological and secular goals.

The book covers a variety of topics in each of its nine chapters.  Peters begins with an introductory chapter on the relation between God and DNA, and the types of determinism ("Puppet" and "Promethean") that dominate the discussion of human genetics and freedom.  Then there are two chapters on the genetic determinants for behavior, such as the "Crime Gene" and the "Gay Gene."  This is followed by a chapter on the commercial use and patenting of genes.  And then a series of chapters on germ-line therapy, the cloning controversy, and stem cell research.  Peters closes the book with a chapter outlining his "Theology of Freedom," arguing that genetic determinism is not supported by science, and that theological concerns offer a way to guide future use of genetic technologies.  The book is an update of the 1997 edition.  The updates consist of supplementary passages in the introductory chapter and the addition of new chapters on cloning and the stem-cell controversy.  As in the first edition, Peters also includes two appendices, one on the CTNS statement on the Gay Gene Discovery, and another on "Playing God with David Heyd."  The book includes notes for each chapter and an index.  The book is most appropriate for the informed layperson or undergraduate level courses.

Peters' book is a welcome attempt to discuss the theological arguments about the use or misuse of genetic technology, and some of the misconceptions about human freedom and DNA.  He goes some way in showing that many of the religiously motivated arguments are based on false assumptions (viz. the gene myth), however, his gloss of several points leaves the reader somewhat dissatisfied.  A couple of chapters stand out as particularly successful, yet the book as a whole represents an awkward and often times confusing mix of philosophical argumentation and Christian apologetics.  This is not a book this reviewer would recommend as a comprehensive introductory survey to the topic of genetic determinism, but it does present itself as a curiosity for the interested reader.

 

© 2003 Bryan Benham

 

Bryan Benham is an Assistant Professor (Lecturer) in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Utah.  His research areas are philosophy of mind and applied ethics.